Is the Internet good or bad for us?

Submitted by acohill on Fri, 12/31/2004 - 08:30

The New York Times (reg. required) has an article summarizing a new study on the impact of the Internet on our lives. As past studies have found, TV is the big loser, with Internet users watching about 17% less television. That's probably not bad news.

The article goes on to say that the Internet is also causing us to sleep less (by 8.5 minutes) and that it reduces contact with family members by 23.5 minutes per day. The researchers acknowledged that they cannot answer the question of whether or not it strengthens or weakens social relationships. That's been a burning question since the rise of the Internet, and many tons of paper was wasted in the mid and late nineties to print handwringing articles about how the Internet would probably turn us all into introverted, pale-faced geeks sitting in our basements in the dark night after night, hanging out in seedy chat rooms.

None of that ever happened, but this study is likely to produce an echo effect of those hysterical articles, using the data that contact with family members is down.

The problem with these studies is I have yet to see one that really tries to find out the other side of the story. I may talk slightly less to my wife face to face, but we are emailing each other all day long. So if you really studied the entire social interaction, you'd probably find we communicate more now than we did ten years ago.

The article estimates that 75% of the country has Internet access now. Unfortunately, we still have some elected leaders in our communities that don't think any of this is important, because they are viewing it through the lens of their own (somewhat limited) experience, rather than trying to look at the community as a whole. When 75% of your constituents are using the Internet, it's not a fad or a luxury for the well off--it's a necessity of daily life. In rural communities, the Internet has broken the chains of rural isolation and dramatically improved the quality of life in areas like shopping. Living in a rural area no longer means long drives (or doing without) to obtain needed items--a couple of clicks online and the products are delivered to your door, or even via broadband, if you don't live near a well-stocked music store, as just one example.

1995 was the year the Internet really took off. Ten years later, we've gone from a tiny number of people who had Internet access back then to 75% of the country--that's the fastest diffusion of a new technology ever. We're on to something here, and I believe it's mostly for the good. We're more aware of world events, better informed on local, national, and international issues, have more control over our time, and have all kinds of new business and work opportunities available to us.

Just one example: despite the sheer awfulness of the tsunami, we all know about it in a way that we never could have even five years ago, to say nothing of ten or twenty years ago. Is the knowing a good thing? Well, charitable giving, propelled by hundreds and thousands of Web sites helping to organize aid, will likely break every fundraising record in the world.

In the face of horrible suffering and pain, the Internet gives us an opportunity to demonstrate our basic humanity and caring for others--an opportunity to rise above our own needs, to rise above political, social, economic, and language differences--and we are doing so.

Happy New Year--all my best for a prosperous and healthy 2005.

Andrew

spelling mistake

The article goes on to say that the Internet is also causing us to sleep less (by 8.5 minutes) and that it reduces contact with family members by 23.5 minutes per day. The researchers acknowledged that they cannot answer the question of whether or not it strengthens or weakens social relationships. That's BEE a burning question since the rise of the Internet, and many tons of paper was wasted in the mid and late nineties to print hand-wringing articles about how the Internet would probably turn us all into introverted, pale-faced geeks sitting in our basements in the dark night after night, hanging out in seedy chat rooms.

isn't it supposed to be BEEN?

Fixed!

Thanks! I've corrected the typo.

Best regards,
Andrew

yes it is

yes it is

Loved this article! It is

Loved this article!
It is pretty well going to be my main source for my essay!
Haha, great work.

haha same nice article BTW

haha same
nice article BTW

i love this article

i love this article

Helped SO much!

I'm doing this huge essay on the pros and cons of the internet and you wouldn't believe just how much this helped me! Thanks so much! :D

Social Aspects of the Internet: Family

Andrew, an anecdote for you. The relationship of extended family, like my father, has improved solely by the advent of ubiquitous internet access:

I trade emails with my Dad who lives in Florida (spry 89 yrs. old)at least 5 times a week and have for about 10 years now. Prior to that, we spoke probably 3 times a year other than the 3 times I'd go visit. It is a real pleasure to have this instant communication to see how he's doing. I suspect that others have the same story with their extended family members. Probably even extends out to distant cousins that are once in 10 year frequency in the past.

I also find that being able to write simple small things using email is easier than having to compose long hand written snail-mail letters which, more often than not, didn't get written because it seemed like such a chore.

My wife and I do all our "issue" discussions over email because for sensitive issues, face to face is harder for us cowardly humans. It enables us to be calm, rational, and not so self-involved in the face of conflict. My wife will kill me if she reads this, but come on, what good relationship doesn't have its "moments?" As a result, the issues get solved much quicker and with less anguish. Good stuff for a university research project!

Great stuff, and thanks for all the help back in the BEV early days.

oh my god thanks!

that helped so much thank you!i,too,am doing a HUGELY ANNOYING PROJECT on pros and cons for the internet,and well it got deleted so i haave to research again...thanks!!!! :)

I'm doing an essay on the

I'm doing an essay on the pros and cons of the internet so this helped me a lot! Thanks :D

I'm doing an essay on the

I'm doing an essay on the pros and cons of the internet so this helped me a lot! Thanks :D

no

no

i did not read this it was

i did not read this it was way to long!!!!!

THANK YOU SO MUCH IM DOING AN

THANK YOU SO MUCH IM DOING AN ARTICLE ON THIS :)

thanks im doing a history day

thanks im doing a history day project on the internet and this helped me with some of it.

Good article m8. it helped me

Good article m8. it helped me with my essay!

This article helped me alot I

This article helped me alot

I Bless you

A Broadband Properties top 100 company for 2013
A Broadband Properties top 100 company for 2012
A Broadband Properties top 100 company for 2011

Design Nine has been selected as a Broadband Properties / Broadband Communities top 100 company from 2008 to 2013.


Smart 21

Designed by Design Nine, the nDanville fiber network has won the Intelligent Community Forum's Smart 21 award for 2010.

Design Nine provides visionary broadband architecture and engineering services to our clients. We have over seventy years of staff experience with telecom and community broadband-more than any other company in the United States.

We have a full range of broadband and telecom planning, design, and project management services.